Website redesign in Indianapolis, without losing what already works
Most people who want a website redesign have known they needed one for about two years.
What’s been stopping them usually isn’t money or taste. It’s that the current site, for all its faults, works a little. It shows up for a few searches and brings in the occasional call. Nobody wants to pay for a new site and find out it brings in less. So let’s start there.


The part that actually goes wrong
A redesign rarely fails because the design is bad. It fails on the handover.
The old site had forty pages; the new one has twelve, because twelve looked cleaner. Nobody mapped the ones that disappeared, so they now return errors, including the three that quietly brought in most of the search traffic. Page titles got rewritten for elegance and lost the words people actually search. The developer launched on a Friday, and the SEO person, who is a different person, looked at it the following week.
Six weeks later the site looks much better and the phone rings less.
I do the design, the build and the search side myself, so there’s no handover to drop. A brand-new site has nothing to lose. Yours does.
Signs it’s time
- It’s hard to use on a phone
- It takes more than about three seconds to load
- You can’t update it without calling someone
- It’s on a platform or builder nobody supports anymore
- What you sell today isn’t what the site says you sell
- You’re embarrassed to send the link, so you don’t


Signs it isn’t
- You don’t like the colors. That’s a restyle, not a rebuild. Cheaper and faster.
- It isn’t ranking. A redesign isn’t an SEO strategy. New design plus the same thin content ranks just as badly.
- Traffic is fine but leads are down. That’s usually copy, the offer or one broken form. Worth a diagnosis before a demolition.
Send me the link. If one of those is the answer, I’ll tell you and you can keep your money.
How a redesign with me works
- First, what you’ve already got. Which pages get search traffic, what you rank for, where leads come from. Skipping this step is how the pages that mattered get deleted.
- Then the plan. What pages the new site needs, what each is for and what it should rank for.
- Then design and build. WordPress with Divi, so you can edit your own pages afterward. If you’re weighing builders, I wrote about Divi vs Elementor.
- Then the careful handover. Every old URL mapped or redirected, titles and descriptions carried over on purpose, schema in place, sitemap resubmitted and Search Console watched for weeks, not hours.


Proof the rankings survive
Sparq Physical Therapy moved 131 indexed pages, about 60 blog posts and 509 images from Wix to WordPress. I built a custom import tool to move the posts, migrated the full redirect list and matched every title and description. The practice now ranks for 740 keywords, including #1 for “breathing exercises for vertigo.”
Cabinets, Countertops, Flooring was rebuilt from Squarespace to WordPress and has grown from 101 to 1,085 ranking keywords. Smokin’ D’s BBQ made the same move and went from 259 to 771.
What it costs
A redesign is priced on the finished site, so the tiers match a new build:
- One page or blog: starting at $1,200.
- 3–5 pages: starting at $2,500. The most common redesign by far.
- 6 or more pages: starting at $4,000. E-commerce, scheduling, or a lot of existing content to bring across intact.
You get a firm number in a written proposal before you commit. See the pricing page. If the brand needs attention too, logo and identity work starts at $350, and doing both at once is usually the right order.
For context: offshore redesign services advertise from around $600, and established local agencies that publish prices start around $7,500. I’m in between on purpose. What you get for the difference is one person who owns the design, the build and the search result.


When you shouldn’t hire me
- You need it live in two weeks. A 3–5 page redesign takes about four to six, and much of that is the audit and URL mapping that protects your traffic.
- Six people have to approve the design. I work directly with the owner or one decision-maker.
- You need a custom web application. I build excellent WordPress sites, not software products.
- You’re staying on Webflow, Squarespace or a proprietary platform. I’d be learning on your money.
Where I work
I’m in Carmel and work throughout the Indianapolis metro and with businesses across the country. Most of it happens over video and shared files.
Send me the link to your current site and tell me what’s bothering you about it. I’ll look at what it ranks for before we talk, so we’re discussing the real thing.

Frequently asked questions
Will a redesign hurt my rankings?
It can, and that’s the most common way redesigns go wrong, but it’s preventable. Every old URL is inventoried and redirected to its closest equivalent, titles move across on purpose, and rankings are watched for weeks after launch.
How much does a redesign cost?
Starting at $1,200 for one page, $2,500 for 3–5 pages and $4,000 for six or more. You get a firm number in writing before you commit.
How long does a redesign take?
About four to six weeks for a typical 3–5 page site.
Will my site go down during the redesign?
No. The new site is built separately and goes live in one switch.
Can you keep my current branding?
Yes. If the branding is also holding you back, I’ll tell you.
Do I need a full redesign or just an update?
Send me the link and I’ll tell you honestly. A dated look on a sound structure is a restyle, and it costs less.